Baker Home Solutions

Skylight Leaks: Repair vs. Replace (How to Decide & What Good Work Looks Like)

A dripping skylight doesn’t always mean you need a new one. The trick is knowing whether a targeted repair will solve it—or if a full replacement is the smarter, longer-term move. Here’s a clear guide for Southern Maryland homeowners.

How to Spot the Source

  • Ceiling stains around the light shaft → often flashing or roof leaked above
  • Water between panes or fogging → failed skylight seal/insulated glass
  • Drips only during wind-driven rain → weak step flashing or sealant at the uphill side
  • Damp drywall after snow/ice → missing/short ice-and-water shield around the opening

 

When a Repair Is Enough

  • Flashing failures: Re-flash with proper step flashing at the sides, apron at the bottom, counterflashing at walls/chimneys nearby, and add ice-and-water shield 18–24″ around the opening.
  • Brittle pipe boots/nearby shingles: Replace adjacent materials so new flashing ties in correctly.
  • Sealant refresh: Only for hairline gaps—should never be the primary waterproofing.

A proper repair includes shingle removal/reinstall, new underlayment, and manufacturer-style flashing—not surface caulk.

Signs You Should Replace

  • Aged unit (15–20+ yrs): with crazed/cracked acrylic or failed glass seals
  • Deck-mounted unit: repeated leaks from warped frames
  • Fixed skylight: where ventilation is needed (swap to venting for humidity control)
  • Energy upgrades desired: modern glass is far more efficient and UV-stable

 

What a Quality Replacement Includes

  1.  Measured-to-fit skylight: we recommend modern units like venting, laminated, LowE/argon glass
  2.  Factory flashing kit: matched to your roof material and pitch
  3.  Ice-and-water shield: fully wrapping the curb/opening and lapped correctly
  4.  New shingles: integrated into the field (no “patchwork” shortcuts)
  5.  Interior finish: reinsulated shaft, drywall/trim repair, and paint-ready surface
  6.  Ventilation check: confirm ridge/soffit balance to reduce condensation risk

Cost Drivers (What Affects Price)

  • Roof pitch and height safety/staging
  • Skylight size, fixed vs. venting, manual vs. solar/electric
  • Interior shaft depth/finishing needed
  • Condition of surrounding shingles and underlayment

 

Maintenance Tips to Stay Leak-Free

  • Keep gutters/downspouts clear: reduce splash back around the opening
  • Trim overhanging limbs
  • After major storms: scan ceilings for new stains and call early if you see any
  • Annual tune-ups: consider roof & skylight checkups to refresh seals and catch issues

 

FAQs

Can you repair an acrylic dome skylight?
Yes—if the dome is intact and the issue is flashing/underlayment. Cracked or UV-brittle domes usually warrant replacement.

Do new skylights really improve efficiency?
Modern Low-E, argon-filled glass drastically reduces heat gain/loss versus older units.

How long does a replacement take?/strong>
Most are completed in a single day, with interior finishing shortly after.